Book on Clutter murders holds new evidence

Posted: Updated:

Sixty years ago, one of the most brutal and heinous crimes shook Holcomb, Kansas and the surrounding area.

Richard Hickock and Perry Smith broke into the home of Herb Clutter, killing him, his wife and two teenagers.

But what if we still don’t know the whole story? One author says, we still don’t know everything.

“Why would they kill an entire family for just forty bucks? That made no sense,” Gary McAvoy, author of And Every Word Is True, said. “Smith and Hickock definitely did the deed. They killed the Clutter family.”

When the two men broke into the Clutter home, they claimed to have a diagram drawn up by a man they met in prison – Floyd Wells. They wanted to rob the Clutters – but wanted much more than the small amount at the home.

McAvoy said the problem with that claim, is that Wells had never been to that house before.

“Floyd Wells could not have drawn that map because he’d never been in the new house,” he said. “he was hired by Herb clutter for only seven months and his term ended months before the family moved into the new house. So he couldn’t have drawn that map.”

He said there are more contradictions but there’s still no question the two were guilty. But he suspects there was a third person involved.

McAvoy said his book is an addition to Truman Capote’s book, “In Cold Blood” and he’s simply trying to add to the story we already know.

“Capote’s fine writing, brought about an otherwise obscure case,” he said.

To learn more about McAvoy's book, click here.

Check out these photos from across KAKEland snapped by our viewers, staff and local officials. Do you have pictures to share with us? Email them to