Virginia teacher fired for refusing to use male pronouns for transgender student files lawsuit

Posted: Updated:
CNN -

A Virginia teacher has filed a lawsuit saying he was wrongfully fired for refusing to use male pronouns for a transgender student.

In 2018, a student at West Point High School began identifying as male. He and his mother asked for him to be referred to with his preferred name and pronouns: he, him, his.

French teacher Peter Vlaming said he couldn't "in good conscience" comply, citing his religious beliefs, according to the complaint. He consistently used the student's preferred male name and attempted to avoid the use of any pronouns at all, according to his lawsuit.

The school, according to the lawsuit, gave the teacher an ultimatum: Use the student's preferred pronouns or lose your job.

    School officials suspended the teacher for insubordination. Vlaming was ultimately fired after he refused to use the male pronouns and for repeatedly ignoring orders from his bosses.

    "Mr. Vlaming's conscience and religious practice prohibits him from intentionally lying, and he sincerely believes that referring to a female as a male by using an objectively male pronoun is telling a lie," the lawsuit argues.

    CNN has reached out to West Point Public Schools for comment and has not heard back. The school is about 40 miles east of Richmond.

    A spokesperson for West Point Public Schools said in a statement to The Washington Post that its board denies any wrongdoing. "West Point Public Schools' primary focus is on students, staff, and instruction," the spokesperson said. "We will continue to direct our energy toward maintaining a high-quality learning environment in our schools."

    Vlaming worked with the district for seven years. The decision to fire the teacher came after a virtual reality exercise in the classroom, where Vlaming called out, "Don't let her hit the wall!" as the transgender student walked in that direction, the lawsuit states.

    The student waited for all the students to leave class that day before approaching the teacher, the lawsuit says.

    "Mr. Vlaming, you may have your religion," the student said, according to the suit, "but you need to respect who I am!"

    Vlaming said it was an unintentional slip of the tongue.

    School officials said the educator was insubordinate and failed to follow directives from administrators. And, officials said, the teacher could not be allowed to treat the transgender student differently.

    "That discrimination then leads to creating a hostile learning environment. And the student had expressed that," Superintendent Laura Abel told the Richmond Times-Dispatch late last year. "The parent had expressed that. They felt disrespected."

    The firing led to petitions as well as a student walkout in support of Vlaming. Students held signs saying "men are men and women are women" and "facts don't care about your feelings," CNN affiliate WWBT reported at the time.

    The former teacher is now suing the school district officials, saying they breached his contract and discriminated against him, violating his right to speak freely and his religious freedom. He is seeking $500,000 in lost wages and benefits, plus $500,000 for loss of reputation, pain, suffering and emotional distress. He is asking to get his job back or another position at equal or higher pay.

      "This isn't just about a pronoun, it's about what that pronoun means," Tyson Langhofer, director of the ADF Center for Academic Freedom, said in a statement. "This was never about anything Peter said or did; only about what the school was demanding he say. Nobody should be forced to contradict his core beliefs just to keep a job."

      The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee's Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Resource Center has previously talked about the importance of pronouns in referring to transgender people. "It is a privilege to not have to worry about which pronoun someone is going to use for you based on how they perceive your gender. f you have this privilege, yet fail to respect someone else's gender identity, it is not only disrespectful and hurtful, but also oppressive."

      • NEWSNewsMore>>

      • Halstead overrun with cats, humane society spaying and neutering

        Halstead overrun with cats, humane society spaying and neutering

        Feral cats are running rampant in Halstead and residents are fed up with the problem. 

        Feral cats are running rampant in Halstead and residents are fed up with the problem. 

      • Community invited to KAKE-TV's 65th Anniversary Celebration

        Community invited to KAKE-TV's 65th Anniversary Celebration

        Everyone is invited to celebrate KAKE-TV's 65th anniversary at a special community event.  

        Everyone is invited to celebrate KAKE-TV's 65th anniversary at a special community event.  

      • Residents call state of Mayor's race "dirty"

        Residents call state of Mayor's race "dirty"

        The decision of who should lead the City of Wichita has become more controversial than some voters had suspected.

        The decision of who should lead the City of Wichita has become more controversial than some voters had suspected.

      Check out these photos from across KAKEland snapped by our viewers, staff and local officials. Do you have pictures to share with us? Email them to news@kake.com.

      MORE SLIDESHOWS HERE

      • Most Popular Stories

        • CHRIS NEAL / FOR THE KANSAS NEWS SERVICE

          People in the emptying parts of rural Kansas insist 'we're not going to let them die'

          Rural Kansas has a storied past, but decades of population decline stand poised to turn many once-vibrant places into ghost towns.

        • WKOW photo

          An African American security guard asked a student to not call him the N-word. That request got him fired

          An African American security guard told a student to stop calling him the N-word. It cost him his job. Marlon Anderson was a security guard at Madison West High School in Wisconsin. Last Wednesday, he was called in to help the assistant principal escort a student from school grounds, he told CNN. The student was resisting, including yelling and pushing the principal. Anderson called for backup, and the student started yelling expletives at him, including the racial slur, Anderson sa...
        • Police investigate after man found dead in north WIchita canal

          Wichita police are investigating after a body was found in a canal in north Wichita.

        • Gabe Eye (GoFundMe)

          Hutchinson football player in ICU after injury during game

          A Hutchinson High School football player remains in intensive care after he was injured during a game earlier this week. 

        • Commercial retail in Wichita slow to pick up on national trends

          Some of the latest trends in commercial retail show we can expect to see more innovative entertainment and dining options. Clothing brands may open a store simply for customers to try on clothes and get fitted for sizes. Retailers have created temporary pop-up shops with interactive experiences to test their newest products. And the Esports industry continues to thrive, with Simon Property Group investing $5 million earlier this year into esports promotion and arena operator A...
        • Tulsi Gabbard

          Hillary Clinton implies Gabbard is favored by Russia and could run a third party race

          Hillary Clinton appears to call Democratic presidential candidate Tulsi Gabbard "the favorite of the Russians" in a recent interview, while also describing 2016 Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein as "a Russian asset." During a podcast appearance on Campaign HQ with David Plouffe, the former U.S. secretary of state and 2016 Democratic presidential nominee did not mention the Hawaii congresswoman by name, but says she believes the Russians have "got ...

        • Man dead in southeast Wichita shooting

          A man is dead following shooting outside a home in southeast Wichita. It happened around 4 a.m. Friday in the 4400 block of East Bayley Street.

        • Mom diagnosed with cancer early in pregnancy gives birth to healthy boy

          When Jade Devis of Rancho Cucamonga was diagnosed with a rare form of breast cancer during the first trimester of her pregnancy, she was warned that a difficult and dangerous road lay ahead. 

        • Halstead overrun with cats, humane society spaying and neutering

          Feral cats are running rampant in Halstead and residents are fed up with the problem. 

        • Jury recommends death penalty for 'Boy Next Door Killer'

          A Los Angeles jury recommended the death penalty Friday for a man dubbed “The Boy Next Door Killer” after he was found guilty of two murders and an attempted murder. The victims of 43-year-old Michael Gargiulo included 22-year-old Ashley Ellerin, who was killed on a night in 2001 when she had plans with actor Ashton Kutcher. He testified during the trial that he arrived late for his date with Ellerin, looked into her house when there was no answer at the door, and saw wh...