Tiller Plea to High Court
Save Email Print
Updated: 4:30 PM Feb 1, 2008
Tiller Plea to High Court
Attorneys for Wichita abortion provider Dr. George Tiller have taken their case to the Kansas Supreme Court.
Posted: 4:15 PM Feb 1, 2008
Email Address: cayle.thompson@kake.com
Font Size:

Attorneys for Wichita abortion provider Dr. George Tiller have taken their case to the Kansas Supreme Court.

Papers filed early Friday with the state's highest court ask judges to throw out a grand jury investigation into Dr. Tiller. Only a few hours later in Sedgwick County Court, a judge upheld his Tuesday decision, forcing Tiller to turn over some 2,000 patient file numbers to the grand jury. Prosecutors say the patient records are needed to determine if Tiller broke the law by giving late-term abortions to women who did not need them.

State law allows late-term abortions in cases where the mother's health is at significant risk if the pregnancy continues.

Friday, Sedgwick County Judge Paul Buchanan said names on the files could be blacked out, but patient identification numbers must remain. That troubles Tiller's attorneys.

"The problem... is that the file numbers themselves reveal patient identifying information," said defense attorney Dan Monnat. He compared this inquest into patient records with that of former Attorney General Phill Kline in 2006. In that investigation, Monnat says Kline was able to cross-reference patient ID numbers with hotels in the area where out-of-town patients had stayed, thereby deriving their names.

"We think that he violated the late-term abortion law and that it will show in the patient records," said David Gittrich, state development director for Kansans For Life, a pro-life advocacy group. "We don't care who the people are."

Prosecutors say the names will be protected, and that grand jury information is well guarded from the public. Still, Tiller's attorneys fear a leak could jeopardize patient privacy laws.

Pro-life advocates say Tiller's attorneys are only delaying the grand jury process -- forcing the clock to run down on the jury's 90 day deadline in which it must decide whether to file charges. Tiller's attorneys say this is not about delays, but about patient rights.

"Those subpoenas cannot be enforced and this grand jury needs to be disbanded because it's unconstitutional," Monnat said.

Monnat expects a decision from the Kansas Supreme Court on whether to stay grand jury proceedings by the end of Friday or Monday. If approved, the grand jury investigation would have to stop until both sides have a chance to argue their case before the high court.

National AP Video
Twitter News Feed
    Offbeat News Headlines
    SUV Hits Elephant That Escaped From Okla. Circus
    0 Comments
    An Oklahoma couple driving home from church hit an animal — a really big one. (Full Story)
    Student May Not Get $10,000 Prize For Field Goal
    2 Comments
    A University of Montana student who kicked a field goal to win a $10,000 prize likely won't get the money because he hadn't been away from the sport long enough. (Full Story)
    Ball, Big Wheel, Game Boy Make Toy Hall of Fame
    0 Comments
    Bounce it, kick it, catch it. Chase, throw or smack it. The ball, arguably the most popular plaything of all time, has finally earned a place inside a glass case at the National Toy Hall of Fame in New York. (Full Story)
    Elevator To Space? They're Really Trying
    2 Comments
    A laser-powered elevator to space isn't getting to the top floor. (Full Story)
    Robbery Victim IDs Suspect From Old Yearbook
    1 Comment
    After being robbed of his jacket, cell phone, keys and $300, a Pennsylvania man was left with the odd feeling that his assailants looked familiar. Police say that's because they went to school together about 15 years ago. (Full Story)
    Gone To The Dogs: LA Church Starts Pet Service
    2 Comments
    The pastor of a Los Angeles church has an idea he hopes will draw new followers and help his church reconnect with the community. (Full Story)
    More Headlines
    Extras
    Happy Thanksgiving!
    Your 2009 Thanksgiving Guide
    H1N1 News
    Click here for the latest news regarding the H1N1 virus.
    Upickem Pigskin Payoff Contest
    Click here to go to our pro football season contest!
    First United Methodist Church of Wichita
    Click here to watch Sunday services live.