Station Info ·  Stay Connected ·  Online Extras
Home   ·   News   ·   Weather   ·   Sports   ·   Lottery   ·   Health Info TV  ·   Recipes  ·   A Greener KAKEland  ·   Blogs
Stay Connected With KAKE
E-News
Local news and weather delivered to your inbox twice a day
Health Info TV
Get the latest health news & reports

Kansas Now 22
24-hour local news, weather and sports on Cox Cable channel 22

KAKE First Alert
Instant access to local news and weather
KAKE On Your Cell
News, weather, sports and more on your cell phone or PDA
News Tip
Send your news tips to KAKE
As Seen On KAKE-TV
ABC
Your favorite ABC shows and ABC news programs

Johnson's Garden Time
Gardening Advice from the pros at Johnson’s Garden Centers
KAKE Sports Overtime Live
More than the scores, more than the highlights - every Sunday night at 10:35 PM

Lawyer on the Line
Roger Riedmiller, Esq. answers your legal questions
News Poll
What do you think is the biggest threat to the U.S.?

The energy crisis
Terrorism


Garden City Police Accused of Racial Profiling Save Email Print
Posted: 8:10 PM May 12, 2008
Last Updated: 8:10 PM May 12, 2008
Reporter: Elyse Molstad
Email Address: elyse.molstad@kake.com

A | A | A

The Garden City Police Department has been accused of racial profiling after a woman was arrested in what turned out to be a case of mistaken identity.

After a year-long investigation, the Kansas Human Rights Commission has ruled that the arrest of Adaleena Garcia is a case of racial profiling.

Last year, Garcia was pulled over for having a faulty taillight. When the officers ran her driver's license number, the information came back registered to an Emporia man with outstanding arrest warrants and immigration violations.

Her teenage daughter watched in disbelief as officers patted down, cuffed and arrested Garcia.

As time went by, officers realized their mistake. They had entered the wrong license number.

"We found indeed it was the wrong person and we un-arrested her and apologized for the inconvenience of the brief detention."

Although her detention was brief, Garcia said that she is still emotionally traumatized by the ordeal.

"A year later, I still feel nervous when a police officer is around me..my stomach hurts my hands get shaky, but I think what I did was right and I'm helping other people speak because they're scared to tell on the police," Garcia said.

Garden City Police have filed an appeal asking the Human Rights Commission to reconsider its ruling.

"We disagree with the finding of profiling. While we feel errors were made in the incident-they don't rise to the level of profiling in any shape or form."

The Police Department said it is willing to take any of the Kansas Human Rights Commission's recommendations into consideration for adoption.

In the meantime, their ruling has given Garcia the right to proceed with a civil
lawsuit if she chooses to do so.

More Stories
Man Rushed To Hospital After West Side Bar Fight

Local Raceway Reopens

Hundreds View Traveling Vietnam Exhibit

Teen Dies In Marion Co. Crash

Missing 9-Year-Old Girl Located

Tiahrt Urges Bush To Reject Pressure On Tanker Bids

FEMA Awards $52 Million For Winter Storm Damage

Kansas Employment Rates Remain Steady

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: cliff Location: wichita on May 15, 2008 at 12:52 PM
Anonymous, I am an electrician, a lot more electricians have been killed on the job keeping light and heat in your house in wichita than law enforcement officers in the whole state. try climbing a pole in a thunderstorm to get power back on. 256 deaths for all reasons since statehood isnt very much. certanly not enough to condone the fear.

Posted by: cliff Location: wichita on May 15, 2008 at 09:26 AM
I have very litle respect for law enforcement due to the way they act. they are trained to shoot for "center body mass" inother words, the heart. the courts suppoort them beating and breaking the arm of a diabetic woman because " they thought she was drunk" tasing anyone at will, and lots of beatings, tasings, and shootings because they "fear for their lives" a lot of fear since only 256 have been killed in over 100 years. inlcuding those "hero's" like the lieutenant that was killed when blowing up fireworks at the bomb range, he talked on his radio after wireing up electric blasting caps to the explosives.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Wichita on May 15, 2008 at 08:34 AM
Cliff is part of that liberal, tree-hugging, criminal coddling element that will never appreciate the job that anyone else does, only his own. Let him lead his pathetic, lonesome life judging others imperfections through this blog. By the way, sounds like an innocent mistake by the police. I could see being upset if she was held for hours. I don't see where the racial issue plays any significant part in this. The board should have a law enforcement representative on the commission to explain or clarify the legal authority the police operate under and explain how they are trained to look for certain things the general public wouldn't think of. 99.9% of them do an excellent job and we appreciate it.

Posted by: cliff Location: wichita on May 15, 2008 at 07:21 AM
I hope to never have to cal the cops in a crisis, the response time is lousy, and they are not really very helpfull, just arogant and usuallyh have their hands on their guns so they can shoot someone faster.

Posted by: unknown Location: Wichita on May 14, 2008 at 11:22 PM
Who are your going to call the next time you're in a crisis Cliff? Gee haven't you read the news the past couple of days. Seems there is a freak on the loose wanting to shoot officers. Not very dangerous, huh? You seem very wise indeed.

Posted by: james on May 14, 2008 at 09:59 PM
To the officers, just remember who you are and why you wear the uniform. To Serve and protect the citizen of GCK. Don"t let one taillight mis-guide you. In the old days your word and a hand shake was all it took for apology, now it is who I can sue and for how much.

Posted by: cliff Location: wichita on May 14, 2008 at 02:29 PM
total for the state, 656 ofrficers killed by all means since the state became a state. still dont sound like a very dangerous job. nobody forces anyone into law enforcement. since the local courts and such go along with the protect yourself, shoot first, dont bother with questions afterwords methods now days, you would think it is a very dangerous job.

Posted by: Bill Location: Garden City on May 14, 2008 at 01:17 PM
To Cliff, what do you do for a living? I'm sad that you think 28 officers isn't a big deal. When everyone is running away from a disaster, police officers and firefighters are running into it. Get over yourself.

Posted by: cliff Location: wichita on May 14, 2008 at 07:01 AM
for the men and women who risk eheir lives dailey, only 28 law enforcement officers have been killed in sedgwick county and wichita in a hundred years, not much risk there, considering how many of them there are.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Garden City on May 13, 2008 at 06:21 PM
The commission was completely wrong but that was predictable. No surprises there. The surprise would have been them having the courage to decide a case based upon facts and not skin color. Also, no surprises on this bit of reporting. The most racist thing I saw in the piece was the statement by the lawyer. I found it offensive. Another failure for this TV station. Again, predictable. The only constant in this seems to be the complete professionalism of the GCPD. I am proud to have them protecting my community. A mistake was made, it was admitted to and made right as quickly as possible. That is the right thing to do, and they did it. I wish others in this case were doing the right thing as well.

Posted by: Jessica Location: Garden City on May 13, 2008 at 03:46 PM
To all those that criticize the police. It’s amazing how quickly you are to judge the men and women that risk their lives on a daily basis. Who are you going to call when you’re in trouble? A crack dealer? People make mistakes, the officers apologized for it and she was released immediately. Matthew 5:9, Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called sons of God.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 13, 2008 at 12:11 PM
The faulty tail light story?! All cops use that one because they are profiling may it be racial or just your appearance,I have been told by a WP officer(friend) they do it all the time(hoping to catch a bad guy and be the hero for the day!)Power tripping is what it is.The officers should have clearly seen the moment they ran her license when it came up a MALE that had made a error, but they were so quick to jump and arrest her<

Posted by: unknown Location: midwest on May 13, 2008 at 11:52 AM
My husband is American Indian and years ago he was the victim of mistaken identity. A warrant was out for a man with a similar last name. The police surrounded his house and put him in handcuffs. They realized their mistake. The Human Rights Commission was not contacted and it never entered my husband's mind to file a lawsuit. He wasn't happy at the time but he understood it was a mistake. He didn't use the race card either.

Posted by: Lydia Location: Wichita on May 13, 2008 at 10:55 AM
I agree completely with Iseees and Jim!

Posted by: AJ Location: Wichita on May 13, 2008 at 10:47 AM
Hey due to a human error lets sue then we can be real lazy in style. I think the suing issue is getting out of hand. Faulty vechiles put everone in harms way I would rather get stopped for a faulity taillight then cause a wreck and kill innocent people.

Posted by: Iseees Location: Wichita on May 13, 2008 at 10:22 AM
To those who didn't read the article clearly and need it spelled out for you... if she wasn't a legal citizen do you really think they would have released her after finding their error? To hush up their mistake they would have pulled the illegal immigrant card just like you other idiots to cover up to not have to deal with a lawsuit. I bet most of you who have posted comments call yourselves upstanding Christians and here you are judging others and throwing stones.

Posted by: Jim Location: Wichita on May 13, 2008 at 09:45 AM
James, are YOU a legal resident? I might suspect you could be an illegal from Europe or Australia who plans to steal and American job! Don't you go having any babies on American soil until every redneck in the country can verify for themself you "belong" here!

Posted by: Jim Location: wichita on May 13, 2008 at 09:22 AM
If I get pulled over for a faulty taillight(already a joke, they are really looking for drugs or alcohol or an excuse to run your name through the system)and I get falsely arrested because some cop punched a wrong number in, I would be mad as well. I would sue as well. What ever happened to true police work? Solving crimes? I would rather they stop pedophiles and murderers than pull me over because my tag light is out, and if you are gonna pull me over, at least do me the favor of putting the right number in idiot.

Posted by: cliff Location: wichita on May 13, 2008 at 08:48 AM
so her name is Garcia and all the local biggots are screaming that it wasnt profileing. the cops messed up and were caught at it. why would the human rights comission findit profileing on the sparse info posted here?

Posted by: Nick Location: Wichita on May 13, 2008 at 07:08 AM
The way it's presented in this story this incident sounds more like a case of human error than racial profiling. I'm a bit skeptical that this woman is as traumatized as she claims to be. She's probably rubbing her hands together with greed when noone is looking.

Posted by: superb Location: Wellington on May 12, 2008 at 11:47 PM
Justice sometimes get delayed because of due-process but it will be achieve by you when you are being honest and patiently working on it through legal way, and of course when you're going to assert then you prove that you are deserving to win justice. "NO perfect person in this world"... Only we need is to try our best to work well with our respective duties in every department or wherever we are in.

Posted by: Dan Location: Wichita on May 12, 2008 at 10:44 PM
Oh lord, now the mexicans are joining in on pulling the race card. The police officers made a mistake....anyone can tell this wasn't racial profiling.

Posted by: mark Location: kansas on May 12, 2008 at 10:16 PM
You have got to be kidding me. This was not racial profiling. As James said, this was a simple case of someone entering the incorrect numbers in the computer. I understand the woman being traumatized if she has not ever been in trouble with the law. However, mistakes happen. We live in a imperfect society. There has only been one perfect person and died over 2000 years ago.

Posted by: millions Location: to mexico on May 12, 2008 at 10:13 PM
well there's more money to be sent to mexico

Posted by: James Location: w on May 12, 2008 at 09:04 PM
This was just an entry error of numbers; anyone could have this happen; just like this station sometimes misspells words online; this is not profiling; more PC nonsense; is this woman a legal resident?

Posted by: Ks Human Rights??? Location: Joke! on May 12, 2008 at 08:35 PM
The Kansas Human Rights commission has NO IDEA what they are doing in investigating these things! Someone needs to oversee them as they are making rulings based on no evidence of such profiling. WAKE UP!

As Seen on KAKE News
Community
Community calendar listing of events happening all across KAKEland
Cost Cutters
Money-saving tips
Entertainment
Ricky's Reviews, ABC Video Player, entertainment news & movie listings
Golden Apple
Nominate an outstanding teacher
GMK Birthdays
E-mail your birthday to Good Morning Kansas
Good Question
KAKE anchor Jeff Herndon provides answers to your good questions
Hatteberg's People
KAKE anchor Larry Hatteberg profiles ordinary Kansans doing extraordinary things
Piece of KAKE
KAKE TV has been the symbol of excellence in Kansas television for over 50 years. Take a look back at its history.
Reading Caravan
Nominate an elementary school library for a $500 grant
Schools
Local school & education news including weather related school closings
Susan's Kids
KAKE anchor Susan Peters profiles local kids looking for an adoptive home
National AP Video