Station Info ·  Stay Connected ·  Online Extras
Partly Cloudy
Temp: 88 F (31 C)
Humidity: 36
Heat Index: 87 F
Home   ·   News   ·   Weather   ·   Sports   ·   Lottery   ·   Health Info TV  ·   Recipes  ·   A Greener KAKEland  ·   Blogs  ·   Crimestoppers
Stay Connected With KAKE
E-News
Local news and weather delivered to your inbox twice a day
Health Info TV
Get the latest health news & reports

Kansas Now 22
24-hour local news, weather and sports on Cox Cable channel 22

KAKE First Alert
Instant access to local news and weather
KAKE On Your Cell
News, weather, sports and more on your cell phone or PDA
News Tip
Send your news tips to KAKE
As Seen On KAKE-TV
ABC
Your favorite ABC shows and ABC news programs

Johnson's Garden Time
Gardening Advice from the pros at Johnson’s Garden Centers
KAKE Sports Overtime Live
More than the scores, more than the highlights - every Sunday night at 10:35 PM

Lawyer on the Line
Roger Riedmiller, Esq. answers your legal questions
News Poll
Who will you vote for in the race for U.S. Senate?

Pat Roberts
Jim Slattery
I haven't decided


Carr Brothers’ Sentencing Save Email Print
Posted: 9:55 AM Nov 5, 2002
Last Updated: 9:55 AM Nov 5, 2002

A | A | A

A jury must decide whether two brothers should be sentenced to death or life in prison for five killings, including a quadruple murder of friends who were forced to engage in sex acts with each other before each was shot in the head.

Reginald Carr, 24, and Jonathan Carr, 22, did not show any visible reaction when they were convicted Monday of the five murders after a nearly two-month trial.

As he had been throughout much of the trial, Reginald Carr was in shackles because he allegedly threatened deputies.

Prosecutors argued that the defendants were motivated by greed and lust and plan to seek the death penalty. Defense attorneys declined comment, saying the trial was not yet over.

The penalty phase is set to begin Tuesday.

Each brother was charged with the same 47 counts, with Reginald Carr facing an additional three counts for being a felon in possession of a firearm.

Prosecutors said in the Dec. 14-15 spree, the men entered a Wichita home and forced two women and three men inside to engage in sexual acts with each other and to withdraw money from ATMs. The women were repeatedly raped before the five friends were taken to a soccer field, forced to kneel in the snow and shot in the back of the head.

The Carrs were convicted of capital murder in the deaths of Aaron Sander, 29; Brad Heyka, 27; Jason Befort, 26; and Heather Muller, 25. Befort's girlfriend, then a 25-year-old teacher, survived the shooting and ran bleeding and naked through the snow to seek help. She identified the Carr brothers as the assailants.

The brothers were also convicted of first-degree murder for the Dec. 11, 2000, shooting of Wichita symphony cellist Ann Walenta.

Lawyers for each of the brothers sought to blame the other for the crimes. Jonathan Carr's attorney said his client was innocent and that Reginald was the leader in the quadruple murder. Reginald's attorney contended that most DNA evidence pointed to Jonathan.

More than 850 pieces of evidence were introduced and 97 witnesses testified. Only five of the witnesses were for the defense and all five testified on behalf of Reginald Carr, not Jonathan.

After the verdict, the victims' relatives hugged each other, as well as prosecutors and an investigator who worked on the case.

More Stories
Newton Soldier Funeral Arrangements

John Edwards Admits Affair; Denies Fathering Child

Slattery Outlines Proposal For Earmark Changes

$100,000 Headed To Chapman For Tornado Relief

Zebra Mussels Found At Cheney Lake

Century II Undergoing Remodel For First Time In 39 Years

Westar Announces Decline In 2nd Quarter Earnings

50th Anniversary Celebration of the Dockum Sit-In

As Seen on KAKE News
Community
Community calendar listing of events happening all across KAKEland
Cost Cutters
Money-saving tips
Entertainment
Ricky's Reviews, ABC Video Player, entertainment news & movie listings
Golden Apple
Nominate an outstanding teacher
GMK Birthdays
E-mail your birthday to Good Morning Kansas
Good Question
KAKE anchor Jeff Herndon provides answers to your good questions
Hatteberg's People
KAKE anchor Larry Hatteberg profiles ordinary Kansans doing extraordinary things
Piece of KAKE
KAKE TV has been the symbol of excellence in Kansas television for over 50 years. Take a look back at its history.
Reading Caravan
Nominate an elementary school library for a $500 grant
Schools
Local school & education news including weather related school closings
Susan's Kids
KAKE anchor Susan Peters profiles local kids looking for an adoptive home
National AP Video