Trains Collide South of Derby
Save Email Print
Updated: 5:50 PM Dec 17, 2007
Trains Collide South of Derby
One of the victims remains in critical condition in a Wichita hospital.
Posted: 10:10 AM Dec 17, 2007
Email Address: news@kake.com
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Fred Location: Derby on Dec 20, 2007 at 08:52 AM

James, that was my point exactly.. Railroads are the way to go. As far as CTC, I know that the WB train was moving from Main to Main 1 and was trailing through the CTC point. The EB would have had a diverging approach at the previous signal. There is no way anything other than Stop could have been indicated at the signal the EB got by since the plant was occupied. And, anonymous, even though the tracks run North and South, it is Railroad East and West.
Posted by: james Location: kansas on Dec 19, 2007 at 04:02 PM

granted, CTC isn't flawless. all a dispatcher can do to "override" the system is for the crew to flag a stop indication and that will put them at restricted speed. so they should have stopped short of the other train. unless the signal dept. wired the signal wrong since the last train had passed, a dispatcher cannot give a proceed indication into an occupied track circuit. also, if a switch is out of correspondence, the circuit will not clear for the dispatcher to light anyone up. but all these points are moot if it was indeed a signal system failure. and yes, sadly the boards are short this time of year which can lead to crew fatigue
Posted by: the facts Location: kansas on Dec 19, 2007 at 12:58 AM

First off just because it is CTC doesn't mean it is flawless. I have seen it fail a few times as a Conductor. And James if you really know.. then you need to think because the dispatcher can overide. Unfortunately you may be right about someone missing a signal. But, what do you expect when you are 12-17 hours on and 6 1/2 off because they cut the boards so short this time of year. My bet is still on the signal system failing... probably a switch out of correspondense due to icy weather and traffic. Unruh you have no clue how many lives are saved by trains taking trucks off the road. One Stack Train eliminates atleast 266 cross country trucks and saves the fuel economy that much more. Oh and it is more safe. And as far as city limits go I bet you the Railroad was there before the city in most cases.
Posted by: anonymous Location: here on Dec 18, 2007 at 11:50 PM

my husband drives a big truck and people that drive little trucks and cars can cause the same amount of accidents as big rigs do by the way they cut off the big trucks i have seen it.
Posted by: James Location: kansas on Dec 18, 2007 at 09:03 PM

hey "do your research", nobody mentions the UP because it was a UP run-through empty coal train operated by a BNSF crew. It would be rare for this to come down to the dispatcher, this is CTC (centralized traffic control) territory, unless there is a signal malfunction, it is impossible for a dispatcher to give signals to both trains into each other. Most likely, a red signal was ran by one of the crews. as for fred, lets see those extra 5000 trucks back on the highways and see how many motorists would be killed with the extra traffic. railroads are the way to go
Posted by: Anonymous on Dec 18, 2007 at 09:56 AM

I think NB = Northbound and SB = Southbound
Posted by: DO YOUR RESEARCH Location: kansas on Dec 18, 2007 at 08:23 AM

first of all nobody here really knows what they are talking about beside the women whos husband is an engineer. first red theres not even a NB train get it right its BN standing for Burlington Northern which is the green train, and whats SB you mean SF which means Santa Fe which is the yellow and blue train, which if you people have put it together yet those are older trains and know they have joined becoming BNSF orange and black. you people need to do the research before getting on here and blowing smoke, i work for the railroad and have friends that work for UP union pacific which none of you guys have even mention about that traing being half way ripped down the middle. it comes down to the dispatcher do your research and maybe what you said and what you mean will start making a little more sense huh! Everyone should be thankfull that nobody has died yet and that those injured return back to good health. Everyone that says they come by here to much and this and that are wrong!
Posted by: j Location: close by on Dec 17, 2007 at 11:53 PM

the train co. need to pull thier heads out so they don't KILL more people. I have had people close be killed by trains going way too fast for city limits when it has been blind crossings
Posted by: Fred Location: Derby on Dec 17, 2007 at 11:42 PM

Unruh makes a good point, lets put 4000 or 5000 trucks back on the road to replace just a small portion of the rail traffic contained by a just a few trains.
Posted by: Red Location: Derby on Dec 17, 2007 at 10:36 PM

Actually the trains come through a lot more often than one every ten minutes but that is not what caused today’s wreck and there were no flammable liquids or fertilizer involved. The NB train should have gotten a signal to stop further south until the SB train was in the clear. Either the signals malfunctioned or the crew of the NB ran through a stop signal; time will tell. The thing you should be worried about is fatigued crews. Trainmen works some long shifts and are expected do again the next day on minimal rest. My thoughts and prayers go out for the injured trainmen to make a complete and speedy recovery.
Posted by: Timothy Location: Mulvane on Dec 17, 2007 at 08:50 PM

I saw the accident and one of the engines was pretty much in half. It makes you wonder what happened. You never think that something like this would happened. I am just happy nobody was killed. Hopefully the people involved in the accident get better soon.
Posted by: scott Location: el dorado on Dec 17, 2007 at 11:37 AM

I think the train tracks run north south WEST of K-15.
Posted by: UNRUH Location: DERBY on Dec 17, 2007 at 11:21 AM

THESE TRAINS COME THROUGH HERE ON AN HOULY BASIS!!!!HOW MANY TRAIN ACCIDENTS IS IT GOING TO TAKE BEFORE SOME ACTION IS TAKIN....IT DOESNT TAKE A ROCKET SCIENTIST TO FIGURE OUT WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU MIX FLAMABLE LIQUIDS WITH FERTILIZER....
Posted by: Mel Location: Emporia on Dec 17, 2007 at 10:40 AM

This is a terrible accident, I hope everyone is okay and survives. My husband is an engineer and I know how dangerous this line of work can be.
National AP Video
Twitter News Feed
    KAKE-TV on Facebook
    Extras
    Happy Thanksgiving!
    Your 2009 Thanksgiving Guide
    H1N1 News
    Click here for the latest news regarding the H1N1 virus.
    Upickem Pigskin Payoff Contest
    Click here to go to our pro football season contest!
    First United Methodist Church of Wichita
    Click here to watch Sunday services live.