Fact: To receive free over-the-air digital TV (DTV) signals, there is no such thing as a “HDTV antenna” or “Digital TV antenna”.KAKE Blog Listing
Fact: To receive free over-the-air digital TV (DTV) signals, there is no such thing as a “HDTV antenna” or “Digital TV antenna”.
Topic Author: Jay Prater
Posted: 2:12 PM Feb 19, 2008
Replies Posted: 15 comments
Save Email Print
 del.icio.us   Google   Yahoo  digg
Recent Blog Topics
Fact: All analog over-the-air TV broadcasts will NOT end on February 18, 2009.
Myth: I can’t install an outdoor TV antenna for free over-the-air digital television (DTV) because of my homeowners or condo association, rental or lease agreement, etc.
Myth: I only need a UHF antenna, since all digital television (DTV) stations only broadcast on UHF channels.
Fact: To receive free over-the-air digital TV (DTV) signals, there is no such thing as a “HDTV antenna” or “Digital TV antenna”.
It may only be semantics. But it’s NOT a “switch” in February, 2009. It’s a cut-off.
Fact: “Digital Cable” and “Digital Satellite” doesn’t mean DTV.
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Email (optional):
Location:
Enter Comments:  
   characters left
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.

Fact: To receive free over-the-air digital TV (DTV) signals, there is no such thing as a “HDTV antenna” or “Digital TV antenna”.

The only place a “HDTV antenna” or “Digital TV antenna” exists is in the mind of a marketing agency rep. Not that I have anything against marketing people. I married one!

I don’t know how many times I’ve overheard the attempted up-sell of one of these to someone that’s just acquired a HDTV. I think it’s due more to ignorance, than the salesperson’s greed, since most of them are hourly, and not commission. But, when a “HDTV antenna” costs more than a TV antenna, both having the same construction and performance, the manufacturer is cashing in on consumer confusion.

An antenna, is an antenna, is an antenna.

The same channels VHF 2-13 and UHF 14-69 (It was 14-83 until 1982, remember?) that carry analog television (KAKE Channel 10, for example) can also carry digital television (like KAKE-DT Channel 21 – Virtual 10.1).

Yes, the SAME EXACT frequencies, or TV channels, are used for either an analog or digital TV signal. An antenna picks up whatever radio waves hit it, within its frequency range, or bandwidth. It’s doesn’t know, nor care, if it’s a digital or analog transmission.

So, for example, if you have a VHF antenna that receives a hypothetical local TV channel 11, it will “capture” either an analog or digital signal of equal power, broadcast on that channel, with an equal amount of voltage (in microvolts, you can’t get shocked) or signal level.

See…there’s no need for a fancy new “digital” antenna. Blow the dust off of that old aerial and give her a try. Just make sure you have a VHF antenna, for VHF channels, and/or a UHF antenna, for UHF channels, or a combo VHF/UHF if you need both. (…which you just might. That’s more fodder for another blog.)

Read Comments
Posted by: Jay Prater Location: KAKE
It looks like WINK-TV is currently broadcasting digital at a lower power, making it harder to get. Surf to tvfool.com and use your address for more information. Also, at 30 miles you may want to install a better antenna, either in your attic or outside. You might also call the chief engineer at WINK, and ask if they are working on their digital transmitter/antenna.

Posted by: Robert Location: Fort Myers, Florida
I am having trouble receiving local cbs channel 11. I am running Vista Ultimate. At one time, I could get it, but about a week ago, I had it set to record a program and at the last minute decided to watch it instead of record it. When I told Media Center "do not record", and that moment, the screen went blank on that channel and I haven't been able to get it back since. I've even re-installed Vista, and it's still no go on channel 11. Their transmitters are about 30 miles away and I am using rabbit ears with a uhf circle. Please help if you can. Thanks Robert Bailey

Posted by: Jay Prater Location: KAKE
Surf to tvfool.com and input your address. It will tell you what channels are available, and which direction, and how far away they are. Good Luck!

Posted by: Margaret Gualtieri Location: Long Island New York
We are seriously thinking of ditching cable; new scam of charging for channel boxes for every tv has us looking into antenna reception. How do we find out what stations can be received via an antenna? We've always been told only local channels is this true & how do we discover what's available to us? Thanks for any help you can advise MG tired of high and soon to be higher cable bills

Posted by: Jay Prater Location: KAKE
Don't confuse the digital TV formats of SDTV (standard definition), EDTV (enhanced def) and HDTV (high def), with ATSC digital versus NTSC analog. There will still be tons of upconverted from NTSC analog to SD ATSC digital programming after 2/09.

Posted by: Shawn Location: Colo Springs
Jay I disagree with you on upconversion SD programming. Once Feb 17,2009 aproaches analog SD programming will be no more. Stations all accross America including Kake in Wichita and one of the local stations here in the Springs are currently working on going HD. There is no such thing as upconversion analog tv programming. If upconversion is what you are looking for then there are plenty of upconverting DVD players and recorders for you. Once it becomes digital that's it. I think by then analog will be history. Thanks Jay for sharing your knowledge of tv.

Posted by: Jay Prater Location: KAKE
KAKE-DT is broadcast on channel 21, now. But, it appears as 10.1 on your HDTV. After the analog cut-off, it will be broadcast on channel 10, and still appear as 10.1 on your screen. This assumes that you are using an antenna. It may appear differently via cable and satellite providers.

Posted by: Jay Prater Location: KAKE
Most live sports and prime-time shows are in HD now, not upconverted SD, on the major networks. With the massive library of existing TV content, we will never be free of standard definition TV, true. But, some shows that were shot on film can be remastered into HD, since the film has a better resolution than HDTV. I don't know when local news will be available in HD in Wichita. The smaller the market, the smaller the cash flow. "Going HD" is very expensive, and there is no compensation from the government for being forced to go digital. BTW...power surges from lightning are just as likely via your cable or satellite coax lines, too.

Posted by: Chad Location: Wichita
So - What does it mean when they (government) ID's a TV station number as 10 or 21? What happened with KAKE's station number after conversion? Does it stay as 10 or change up to 21?

Posted by: FJ Location: Salina
I'm so glad to see that we are ADVANCING backwards... yes what I want to do is place a tall lightening rod on my house once again. After growing up in the 50's and 60's and having to make sure the antenna was unplugged during a T-storm. Makes me feel comfortable, specially after spending BIG BUCKS for a HDTV to obtain programming that is mostly nothing more than up-converted Standard TV. Sorry... I do SEE the difference between HD TV and digital TV, and I'm sorry to see the consumers being "scammed" by retail, selling what is going to be the ULTIMATE picture on ur TV screen... ONCE every movie, tv program, local station is sending in high def, will be the time that we can actually enjoy pure HD TV... until that time, we will enjoy upconverted news feeds, movies and tv programs. Until movies are produced in actual High Def and news stations actually produce in High Def we are limited to "digital TV" and digital tv is not the same as High Def TV. People need to realize this. MHO

Posted by: Jay Prater Location: KAKE
If you do, please share your TV DX successes. Thanks

Posted by: Bryce Location: West Wichita
I'll just buy a mega antenna and do my best to pull signals from Topeka, Kansas City, Oklahoma City and Tulsa. My HDTV will probably be angry with me, however, since I have a perfect view of the Colwich transmission towers. Might be interesting to see what I can pull in on crazy ionospheric days!

Posted by: Jay Prater Location: KAKE
Wow, I didn't realize that. I guess the marketing firms just dusted off an old "playbook" for the digital TV generation. FWIW...The addition of color to the Black and White analog NTSC signal didn't increase its bandwidth. It was still 6MHz "wide". So, I have no idea where this "sucking out parts of the signal" myth came from, since a TV antenna's bandwidth covers the entire VHF and/or UHF television bands (100s of MHz wide).

Posted by: Jeff Location: Wichita
This is a sort of "throwback" to 40 years ago, when color TV was making serious inroads to the homes of America, some were conned into believing that their old antenna wasn't good enough for color TV, they needed a "color antenna", unaware that the real issue is whether the antenna has the frequency response to handle all available TV signals without "sucking out" parts of the signal, and resulting in degraded picture or sound quality, or loss of color.